headermask image

header image

Hundreds rally in Tel Aviv to protest Bil’in woman’s death

The following was originally posted on +972 Magazine

Hundreds of Israelis rallied in Tel Aviv Saturday night to protest the death of Bil’in resident Jawaher Abu Rahmah, who died on Saturday morning after inhaling tear gas fired by Israeli forces during the weekly anti-fence demonstration.

The 36 year-old woman was evacuated to a Ramallah hospital on Friday afternoon, after losing consciousness. Doctors attached her to a respirator and treated her for exposure to toxins found in the tear gas, but the patient did not respond. She died at 9 o’clock on Saturday morning, without regaining consciousness.

Bil’in has been the site of weekly demonstrations on Friday afternoons since 2005, when the route of Israel’s security barrier was constructed so that it divided the village proper from much of its agricultural lands. Click here to read about Abdullah Abu Rahmah, Bil’in popular resistance coordinator, who has been in Israel’s Ofer Military Prison for more than one year.

Jawaher was the older sister of Bassam Abu Rahmeh, who was killed in April 2007 when an Israeli soldier shot him in the chest with a high velocity tear gas canister. Another brother, Ashraf Abu Rahmeh, was shot in the foot at close range at an anti-barrier demonstration in the nearby village of Nilin. Ashraf Abu Rahmeh was handcuffed and blindfolded when a soldier shot him, obeying his officer’s command.

The demonstration to protest Jawaher’s death by tear gas asphyxiation was announced mid-morning on Saturday, via Facebook and Twitter. Despite the short notice, it attracted at least 200 people. The crowd was sufficiently large to block traffic across from the Ministry of Defense (Kirya) on Kaplan Street, a main traffic artery that connects to the Ayalon Highway.

Waving mourners’ posters emblazoned with photos of Jawaher Abu Rahmeh captioned in Arabic, and carrying placards with slogans in Hebrew and English, demonstrators chanted in Hebrew: “Citizens, awake! Fascism is already here!” “Barak! Barak! Minister of Defense! How many demonstrators have you killed today?!” ; in English: “Apartheid! Fight back!”; and in Arabic: “Min Ghaza el Bil’in, hurra hurra Falasteen!” (from Gaza to Bil’in, freedom, freedom for Palestine).

Demonstrators holding up a blood-stained Israeli flag (photo: Lisa Goldman)

As the crowd grew and the chanting became more insistent, riot control police, who had previously stood indifferently in front of the area cordoned off for demonstrators, tried to disperse the crowd by wading in and pushing people. The crowd resisted by pushing back. Police quickly changed tactics and began to arrest demonstrators, pushing them to the ground and twisting their arms behind their backs in at least one case, as onlookers jeered and shouted, “Shame! Shame!”

Altogether, eight were arrested – including former Meretz MK Mossi Raz. A Hebrew-language Ynet report includes an embedded video clip that shows police arresting Raz. At one point, a voice can be heard yelling at the arresting officers, “He’s a member of Knesset, you idiots!” Raz says to the police, as they push and drag him toward the police van, “Did you see me resisting arrest? Did you?!”

After the round of arrests, the remaining demonstrators staged a spontaneous sit-in on the road, blocking traffic at the intersection in front of the ministry of defense for more than an hour as police stood by, alternately threatening arrests and trying to negotiate with the apparent leaders of the demonstration. At one point, a young woman seated on the pavement shouted at the police through a megaphone, “Return the people you arrested and we will disperse! Otherwise you will have to arrest all of us by force and there are a lot of us, so think about that carefully!” The demonstrators responded with shouts of approval and applause.

Demonstrators blocked traffic in front of the Ministry of Defense for more than one hour (photo: Lisa Goldman)

Eventually, after having brought traffic on one of Tel Aviv’s main thoroughfares to a halt for about 90 minutes, the demonstrators decided to move to the police station on north Dizengoff Street, where the arrested protesters were being held pending arraignment.

Earlier in the day, Jonathan Pollak, a well-known anti-occupation activist, and human rights attorney Michael Sfard, who represents the village of Bil’in in its struggle to have the route of the security barrier moved, were interviewed on Voice of Israel’s Reshet Bet. Pollak, who was present at the Friday demonstration, reminded the interviewer that 21 demonstrators have been killed by the Israeli army since 2005 – 10 of them minors. None of them was armed, and not even the army ever tried to claim that the demonstrators carried weapons. Pollak also noted that Abu Rahmah was not the first person to die following exposure to tear gas fired by Israeli forces. Another recent victim was Mohamed Abu Sarah, 18 months old, who died when tear gas seeped into his Silwan home while he was sleeping. There have been several other victims of tear gas asphyxiation.

Sfard added emotionally that the army’s version, which included the claim that Jawaher Abu Rahmeh had been released from the hospital on Friday night and died at home, was an absolute lie. The army also claimed that tear gas in standard amounts was used to disperse stone throwers; but according to several eyewitness accounts – including that of +972 Magazine member Noam Sheizaf, who was also present at the demonstration – the soldiers began firing tear gas as soon as they saw the demonstrators. This was well before they reached the fence and certainly before any stones were thrown. Many other witnesses, including this writer, saw that the army blanketed the village in enormous quantities of gas, causing children as young as 8, who were standing at least 150 meters from the fence, to gag and spit up mucus.

According to the website MySay, the army uses a type of tear gas that is the most toxic and dangerous type available. The gas, known by the acronym CS, was outlawed in the UK as far back as 1964 due to concerns over its many side effects – one of which is the potentially deadly accumulation of fluids in the lungs several hours after exposure to the gas.

For more coverage of the death of Jawaher Abu Rahmah:

1,000 protest in Bil’in

Female protestor killed by Israeli forces in Bil’in

Images: Funeral of Jawaher Abu Rahmah

Ynet reporter slurs non-violent movement

Demonstrators ‘return’ tear gas canister to US ambassador’s home

In saying ‘I didn’t know,’ Israelis enable army’s killing of Palestinians

If you liked my post, feel free to subscribe to my rss feeds

10 Comments so far (Add 1 more)

  1. thanks, for the article. I just want to point out that it’s not uncommon to garble the faces of the protesters to avoid further identification by police or other hostile groups and to limit additional repression.
    Two examples: A demonstration against a racist murder within a german courtroom and deportations by the german state: http://media.de.indymedia.org/images/2010/07/285398.jpg
    and a picture from the blokade against europe’s biggest facist march in Dresden, Germany: http://www.flickr.com/photos/steffireichert/4432368778/in/pool-dresden_februar_2010

    (sorry if my english is a bit clumsy, it’s not my mother tounge)

    1. Michael
    on January 2nd, 2011 at 3:23 pm
  2. It seems to me, from reading other sources, that the demonstrations described here were in fact, marred by Palestinian violence.
    These photos demonstrate that conclusively:
    http://www.israelnationalnews.com/News/News.aspx/141470
    In addition, the claim that Jawaher Abu Rahmah was killed by a tear gas attack cannot be substantiated since Fatah authorities refuse to cooperate with an Israeli investigation by supplying medical documents.

    2. Michael Blackburn
    on January 3rd, 2011 at 3:42 am
  3. Michael – Your ‘other source’ is a report that is a regurgitation of the army spokesperson’s press release. The person who wrote it was not present for the event and his article does not answer the demands of basic journalism – eg, obtaining statements from other sources e.g., (the Palestinian presiding physician, people who were present at the demonstration).

    The article contains several erroneous statements. Here are just a few:

    Jawaher Abu Rahmah was never released from the hospital. The Palestinian presiding physician never made that claim; it was the IDF spokesman that first claimed she was released and died at home, and then changed its story.
    The Palestinian physicians did not refuse to release Jawaher’s medical records. The IDF investigators have the records.
    Stones were not thrown before tear gas was launched (I was an eyewitness).
    No-one said that ‘poison gas’ was used. They said that the toxic element in tear gas most likely caused Jawaher’s death.
    The video of Haitham Khatib is only one of at least half a dozen shot by various people who were present at the demonstration. All are available on YouTube. The IDF has not produced any video that shows the demonstrators inciting violence.
    There was no incitement at Abu Rahmah’s funeral on Saturday. Not even the IDF has made that claim.

    3. Lisa Goldman
    on January 3rd, 2011 at 7:18 am
  4. To be honest…. Now i’m worried about your health eighter ;) Please try to avoid the gas as much as possible. (i think my ‘polish mom genes’ are talking here hehe)

    4. Ida
    on January 3rd, 2011 at 1:11 pm
  5. Lisa, I believe that MySay article is factually incorrect.

    CS gas is still used in the UK today, and, according to Wikipedia, at 5 times the strength used in the U.S.

    Further, there is nothing in the BMJ article to support the words used for the link (‘the potentially deadly accumulation of fluids’). Here is the relevant quote from the article itself:

    ”Case studies indicate that shortness of breath, sore throat, and chest pain are the most common pulmonary complaints, and these typically resolve within 30 minutes. Some authors have also reported bronchospasm and laryngospasm. Delayed pulmonary oedema has been described in recent case studies, but permanent long term lung damage seems improbable.”

    It goes on to say that CS related fatalities are more likely to occur when used in confined spaces (e.g. at Waco siege a few years ago), which clearly was not the case here.

    5. Francis James
    on January 5th, 2011 at 1:19 pm
  6. Francis, thanks. Pulmonary oedema is fluid in the lungs, yes?

    At any rate, there is clearly a lot to investigate here. I would be particularly interested in seeing a study on the effects of used regularly against unprotected civilians over many years. The people of Bil’in and other villages in the West Bank have been tear gassed weekly, over several hours, for the past six years. A blood test for toxins administered to all the villagers would be a good place to start.

    And, as we know, Jawaher Abu Rahmah was not the first person to die from inhaling tear gas shot by Israeli forces.

    6. Lisa Goldman
    on January 5th, 2011 at 1:25 pm
  7. Now that this story has been shown to be false, aren’t you embarrassed to have published it as truth on your blog, with no evidence? As a journalist isn’t it your responsibility to gather evidence before coming to conclusions? Or do you now consider yourself a Palestinian activist first and a journalist second?
    All the best,
    Noa

    7. Noa
    on January 23rd, 2011 at 11:53 pm
  8. Noa, the only information proved ‘false’ is the army’s version. http://972mag.com/new-army-version-on-bilin-death-contradicts-previous-claims/

    And the only person who should be embarrassed is you, for coming over to my blog in order to question my integrity. That is the behaviour of a troll.

    8. Lisa Goldman
    on January 24th, 2011 at 12:16 am
  9. Is anyone who points out that a journalist is supposed to have facts considered by you to be a troll?
    Have you seen the results of an autopsy which showed she died as the result of tear gas?
    Even the author that you linked to did not say that she was killed by the tear gas and yet you still claim in more than one article that she was. I find that incredible.

    9. Noa
    on January 24th, 2011 at 2:57 am
  10. Noa. I have seen the attending physician’s report, in which he states the cause of death is tear gas inhalation. Click here and scroll down to ‘Mohamed Aida’ for the link to the report, with his signature. You have not seen any evidence to dispute the physician’s report, because none exists. In fact, the IDF Spokesman’s official position is that the death of Jawaher Abu Rahmah is ‘still under investigation’ (although the army is not doing any actual investigating; it is just spreading disinformation via anonymous sources).

    The evidence supports my position. There is no evidence at all to support your position.

    And yet you have the audacity to question my integrity and accuse me of poor journalism. I find *that* incredible.

    10. Lisa Goldman
    on January 24th, 2011 at 5:41 am

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked *

*
*