headermask image

header image

My response to the investigation: Haaretz

Why us – and why now?

During the second week of November, I was interrogated, “under caution,” by the International and Serious Crimes Unit (ISCU) of the Israel Police. Four months after I had reported about my trips to Lebanon for Channel 10 TV news and “Time Out Tel Aviv,” I was being accused of endangering Israeli security.

I was accused of violating the Law to Prevent Infiltration, a 1954 regulation intended to prevent infiltration from Arab states. I had never heard of the law, which was later amended to forbid Israeli citizens from traveling to enemy states; nor had any of my Israeli friends and colleagues – although many of them have traveled to enemy countries on their foreign passports, as I did using my Canadian passport. The police told me I could face a four-year jail sentence if convicted.

Read the rest here.

Note: the article was commissioned by the editor of the English edition. I hope it will be translated and published in the Hebrew edition next week, but there’s no guarantee that will happen.

If you liked my post, feel free to subscribe to my rss feeds

18 Comments so far (Add 1 more)

  1. Lisa, Daniel Sharon was arrested the other day when he arrived to the country at Ben Gurion airport and faces similar charges to what they have brought against you guys. This is very unsettling!

    1. Yaeli
    on December 14th, 2007 at 12:58 pm
  2. Hi Yael -

    Yes, the news about Daniel Sharon’s arrest was announced the day after I filed my piece. He’s now under house arrest, but I don’t expect he will actually stand trial.

    The Shin Bet interrogated him because they wanted to know exactly what he told the Lebanese police during his interrogations in Beirut, and then they handed him over to the police.

    I suppose the Shin Bet would have held onto him a bit longer if they thought he’d revealed any sensitive information to the Lebanese police, and I don’t think he will be kept under house arrest too long.

    2. lisagoldman
    on December 14th, 2007 at 1:03 pm
  3. Hi Lisa, nice work on the haaretz piece. I will link to my blog. My article on wisdom of this law is forthcoming :)

    3. godlessjew
    on December 14th, 2007 at 1:40 pm
  4. I liked your articles about Lebanon and found them very informative. I’m sorry to hear that the Israeli government is giving you this kind of trouble, and I hope it blows over soon.

    4. Eilanah
    on December 14th, 2007 at 5:16 pm
  5. It’s amazing how much paranoia and incompetence exist in our neck of the woods. Isn’t it?

    And it’s sad how detrimental to peace, to openmindedness, and to a better understanding of our neighbours, this paranoia and incompetence have become.

    5. Bad Vilbel
    on December 14th, 2007 at 8:22 pm
  6. Wow – rereading your Lebanon pieces makes it all the more frustrating. I posted on my blog and made mention of how you are coming to Temple Emanu-El next year :)
    http://www.rabbilandsberg.com/blog/2007/12/lisa-goldman.html

    6. Rabbi Landsberg
    on December 14th, 2007 at 9:04 pm
  7. what happened to Ha-aretz???
    those talkbacks *-*
    it’s like “kahana-chai” is commenting there *_*

    7. tsedek
    on December 14th, 2007 at 11:00 pm
  8. i really enjoyed your haaretz piece: a lovely balance of grace & snark.

    8. miriam
    on December 15th, 2007 at 1:41 am
  9. I have a few thoughts that I can’t quite tie together yet, but here goes:

    Over the past several years, reporters (some good, some who couldn’t carry your jockstrap) in the US have been arrested for or forced to testify about government/military programs they have revealed. The US Justice Department has also said that some reporters could potentially face charges of sedition for such reports. Reporters are routinely condemned as unpatriotic (by other reporters as well as by government officials) and had their work described as “providing aid and comfort to the enemy” (the statutory language for treason). I know these examples don’t apply to you, although the American documentarian Michael Moore has been threatened with and may still face charges for traveling to Cuba for his recent film _Sicko_; his situation seems somewhat similar to yours.

    I don’t know how common it is for Israeli reporters to be targeted by law enforcement over the content of their reports, but when it happens here, it frightens me. It has a noticeable effect on the topics and quality of reports about subjects that are relevant and important, and which form the basis for sometimes extreme actions my government takes in my name and in the name of all US citizens.

    I’m glad you don’t seem too concerned about your own situation; I hope your confidence that it will go nowhere is well-founded. And I really hope you are able to continue researching and writing without having to constantly look over your shoulder to see if the police are just waiting to arrest you. For your sake and mine.

    9. Aaron
    on December 15th, 2007 at 4:07 am
  10. Holy crap! Almost every single commenter on that Ha’aretz thread is a certifiable jibber-jabbering froth-flecked nutbag! (Except for me, of course. My comment, it goes without saying, was elegant yet understated.) They make the commenters on the WaPo’s religion blogs seem like tai chi masters!

    10. Curt
    on December 15th, 2007 at 6:25 am
  11. Curt, I know! Haaretz tends to attract wacko commenters (no idea why), but it looks as though a whole lot more people than usual are off their meds.

    11. lisagoldman
    on December 15th, 2007 at 10:02 am
  12. Lisa’s in good company. You should see the talkbacks to Yair Lapid’s article on ynet. He dared to suggest that the settlers relocate to the Galilee. Oy vey! ;)

    12. Fay
    on December 15th, 2007 at 10:05 am
  13. I guess that the authorities investigated you now in order to scare off other journalists from going to enemy states. That’s the only plausible explanation I can think about. Other than that, there’s absolutely no reason for this investigation many months after your visits to Lebanon, and after it has been all over the media.

    13. Yohay
    on December 15th, 2007 at 12:23 pm
  14. This investigation seems like total Bullshit. Reporters have been going to enemies countries so many times because this is there job. Most of the time those visits are being ignored by the authorities, but at least one time the authorities helped a reporter getting in Lebanon. Itai Engle (by the way in my opinion he is one of the best reporters in Israel), went into Lebanon with an Israeli combat unit during the Lebanon war. Can someone pleas explain the different treatment that each case receives?

    14. adi
    on December 15th, 2007 at 12:32 pm
  15. This is silly. Are you sure this is happening in Israel and not in Iran?

    15. Kamangir
    on December 19th, 2007 at 7:04 am
  16. Lisa:If it is happening in the only democratic country in the Middle East,I don`t undertand nothing as well.
    I am with you,and with the reporters who are under persecution for covering the news.
    I hope your case will be under best way.

    18. Carlos
    on December 20th, 2007 at 11:18 pm
  17. Kamangir, what made you think that it couldn’t be happening here? Why would that be so? Because of the impression? There are numerous examples to prove ‘perpetrating the law’ (even if half of israel is doing so, in some cases) will be held against you whenever it is convenient for whoever wants to accredit profit for personal or national interest out of it, at ANY time. ;)

    19. tsedek
    on December 23rd, 2007 at 7:27 pm
  18. Hi Lisa, thanks for sharing your story. I hope you are doing well. Greetings from Bolivia. – Eddie

    20. eduardo
    on December 29th, 2007 at 4:44 am

2 Trackbacks

  1. [...] آبان امسال واحد جرمهای جهانی پلیس اسراییل اولین بازجویی را ازلیسا بعمل آورد. جرم او به خطر انداختن امنیت اسراییل است. قانونی که بر اساس آن به لیسا اتهام وارد شده است “جلوگیری از نفوذ” نام دارد و در سال ۱۹۵۴ تصویب شده است. به این ترتیب او متهم است که خود را در معرض دزدیده شدن توسط گروههای مخاصم قرار داده و به این ترتیب دولت اسراییل را در خطر مذاکره با دشمنانش و احتمالا آزادی اسرا جنگی قرار داده است (وبلاگ انگلیسی لیسا). [...]

  2. [...] Lisa Goldman may be sentenced to jail for her trip to Lebanon on her Canadian passport (more on her blog). [...]

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked *

*
*