headermask image

header image

On being probed by the Israeli police: or, the Lebanon story just won’t go away

For those enlightened beings amongst my readers who avoid reading the news, I am currently under police investigation, on suspicion of violating the Law to Prevent Infiltration. Yes, this is about my trips to Lebanon.

Two other journalists are also being “probed” – Yedioth Aharanoth’s Ron Ben-Yishai, who reported from Syria in September, and Tsur Shezaf, a freelance journalist who recently wrote about his trip to Lebanon in an Israeli travel magazine called A Different Journey.

The investigation, which is being conducted by the International and Serious Crimes Unit (ISCU) of the Israel Police, raises many questions, such as:

  • Why single out me, Ron and Tsur , when at least a dozen Israeli journalists have traveled to enemy countries over the past six months alone – not to mention the tens of thousands of Israelis with foreign passports who have for years traveled to enemy countries for business, family visits and tourism, with the full knowledge of the authorities?;
  • Why did the ISCU interrogate Tsur over an article he wrote about a trip he made to Lebanon four years ago, while Channel 2’s Itai Anghel has not been questioned over his far more recent trip to Iraq?;
  • Who initiated this investigation, and why?

In my response to the investigation, which will be published on Friday in Haaretz newspaper, I raise these questions and more. I respond to those who claim that I endangered State security because I risked being abducted by Hezbollah, which would force Israel to swap political prisoners for my release. I also explain why my case cannot be compared to the infamous Elhanan Tennenbaum incident.

I have quite a lot more to say, but will wait until after the Haaretz piece is published.

Meanwhile, here are links to bring you up to speed. I’ll update them if something new pops up.

Mainstream media (English):

I was interviewed for the Jerusalem Post, which also published a legal analysis of the investigation.

Sara Miller interviewed me for Haaretz’s English edition online, here.

The Ynet piece is here.

Made it onto an Australian news site.

And Lebanon’s Daily Star, of course.

The International Middle East Media Center (Palestinian).

Al Arabiya.

Oh, and Iran’s PressTV practically has me in jail already.

Ray Hanania wrote an interesting piece for American Muslim.

The International Federation of Journalists is taking up the matter with the National Federation of Israeli Journalists.

This is actually an old piece, but it’s worth a look: the Lebanon Daily Star’s Michael Young weighs in on the reaction to me and Rinat reporting from Lebanon in a piece published by Executive Business Magazine.

Josh Mitnick touches on issues related to freedom of the press in this piece for the New York Jewish Week.

The Jewish Telegraphic Agency

Arabic media:

Exiled Syrian dissident journalist Nizar Nayouf wrote a piece for Syria Truth.

Blogs posts:

The Committee to Protect Bloggers (Curt Hopkins)

Nizo – “May it pass” (it will).

Israel Matsav (by Carl)

Journalist Larisa Alexandrovna

Jewlicious

Israellycool

Harry’s Place.

Liza of SomethingSomething

Rabbi Landsberg

Oleh Girl

Orthodox Anarchist

Brian Ulrich

iFocos

The Rabid Smurf (Lebanese blog)

There’s plenty more in the Hebrew blogosphere and mainstream media, but I’ll let Hebrew speakers do their own googling. Except for this one piece that was published in Yedioth Aharonoth last Friday, which I translated:

The police discovered a security threat: journalists who reported from enemy states

Three journalists who reported from Syria and Lebanon – including Ron Ben-Yishai of Yedioth Aharonoth – were investigated on suspicion of damaging state security

By Itzik Saban/Yedioth Aharonoth

December 7, 2007

The police investigated a journalist because they believed erroneously that he had recently traveled to Lebanon. The journalist Tsur Shezaf, who authors a column titled “A Border Incident” for the travel magazine A Different Voyage, recently wrote about the trips he made to Lebanon in 1977 and 2003. The police investigators read it – and without checking rushed to interrogate him and accuse him of damaging state security.

Officer Roni Ritman of the International and Serious Crimes Unit of the Israel Police (ISCU) decided recently to waste the time of two superintendents of the ISCU with an investigation of journalists who, he claimed, had damaged state security by reporting from Lebanon and Syria. The police regard this as a serious offense punishable by up to four years in prison. “They interrogated me for five hours as if they had caught a terrorist. They insisted on asking from where to where I travelled and if I did so on a donkey or by taxi,” recounted one of the journalists.

The other two journalists who were interrogated last month are Yedioth Aharonoth reporter Ron Ben-Yishai and Lisa Goldman, who reported for Channel 10 and additional publications. Ben-Yishai was interrogated after he visited Syria and wrote about his impressions of Deir el Zor, following the IAF bombing of an area nearby. For some odd reason, nobody at the ISCU took an interest in Ben-Yishai after his visit to the dahiyeh in south Beirut after the Second Lebanon War.

Police sources hinted yesterday that there is a link between the ongoing investigation of former MK Azmi Bishara and the investigation of the three journalists. Several weeks after Ben-Yishai travelled to Lebanon in 2006, Bishara travelled to Lebanon, exchanged hugs with Nasrallah and gave a speech in Bint Jbeil. Later he travelled to Syria and met with Hamas leaders. In an interview he gave to an Israeli newspaper, Bishara asked, “Why are you harassing me? Look, Ron Ben-Yishai travelled to Lebanon too. Are you harassing me because I am an Arab and he is a Jew?”

The police stated that they take a grave view of Israeli citizens who travel to enemy countries – even if they do so using their foreign passports.

***

For me, the most hilarious aspect of this whole story is that it has united a virulently anti-Israel blogger and a virulently anti-Arab blogger – although I don’t think they know about one another’s existence. They would probably say that they are vastly different people, but in fact they have a lot in common:

1. They both really, really hate me – one because I am a right-wing Zionist lick spittle, and the other because I am a dangerous, seditious leftist who panders to the Arabs and endangers the security of the state;

2. They both think that my Channel 10 report from Lebanon was “fluff” and that I was motivated by “self promotion”.

3. They both focused on a statement I made to Haaretz and the Jerusalem Post, in which I explain that I was unaware of the law forbidding Israelis from entering enemy countries on foreign passports. One thinks that I should have stood up and said I was damned proud of breaking the law, and damn the consequences – let the police come and get me! The other thinks I was being disingenuous and I should have bloody well known that I was breaking the law.

4. Both have serious anger management issues, bullying personalities, a strong sense of self righteousness and a gaping hole where their senses of humour should be.

5. Both are convinced that I understand absolutely nothing about the Middle East, whereas they understand everything: Israel is always wrong; or the Arabs are always wrong.

6. They are both American Jews. One lives in the States; and the other immigrated a few years ago, settling in the Gush Etzion area beyond the Green Line.

Funny, huh? Maybe not so much in the ha-ha sense, but more in the weird sense.

Ach, those extremists: they’re all the same.

 

If you liked my post, feel free to subscribe to my rss feeds

17 Comments so far (Add 1 more)

  1. Lisa, if I believed in God you would be in my prayers. Seriously, if there is anything I can do just let me know.

    Roi

    2. godlessjew
    on December 13th, 2007 at 10:21 am
  2. Aw, thanks Roi. I am pretty sure this silly story will blow over soon, unless some macho guys at the ISCU and the attorney general’s office decide to flex their muscles and show everyone who’s boss.

    Still, it’d be pretty difficult to prove criminal intent in a court of law. And besides, if they are really trying to show that the law applies to everyone, they are going to have to put a LOT of people on trial.

    Anyway, there is no precedent of anyone being tried for violating this law.

    3. lisagoldman
    on December 13th, 2007 at 10:41 am
  3. Lisa,

    It’s not true that there’s no precedent. There is one. Azmi Bishara was about to be put on trial for traveling to Syria (and worse) when he disappeared last summer. He and two of his aides were previously charged with violating Section 18(d) of the emergency regulations. It’s on Adalah’s web site. He got off because he was an MK. The aides got community service. And that was for organizing trips for Golan Druze to visit their families – not for either what he and other Arab MK’s did later or what you are being questioned about doing.

    The Knesset has made a couple of efforts in recent months to pull the passports of MK’s who travel to Syria and Lebanon. I would argue (as I did on my blog) that they are different than you, and that their motives are different than yours and that looking at the motivation behind the law is an okay thing to do (it’s called “legislative history” and it’s routinely done in the American courts – that’s why there’s a Congressional Record there). But the police have a need to be seen as ‘even-handed’ and that’s why they’ve come after you.

    I hope you have a lawyer. (I’m a lawyer but this is not my specialty; I can recommend someone for you if you’d like). I would NOT take a lawyer who is defending the Arab MK’s – IMHO their interests are at odds with yours. But you definitely should have a lawyer. Good white collar crime lawyers are expensive and I doubt you are independently wealthy. Maybe Channel 10 would be willing to help you out since they sent you in the first place.

    4. Carl in Jerusalem
    on December 13th, 2007 at 10:59 am
  4. Carl, thank you for offering to recommend a lawyer. I do have a very good one, but it’s good to know I have options.

    As far as evenhandedness under the law is concerned, I think this investigation is actually an excellent example of selective application of the law. I allude to this when I mention Itai Anghel’s recent trip to Iraq; Itai has not been questioned by the ISCU, nor have any of the other dozen or so Israeli journalists who have traveled recently to enemy states.

    Nor, for that matter, have any of the thousands of Israelis who travel regularly as private citizens to enemy states, without permission from the ministry of the interior and with the full knowledge of the authorities. It is simply a myth that Israelis rarely travel to enemy states. They do, they continue to do so and they always have.

    5. lisagoldman
    on December 13th, 2007 at 11:05 am
  5. This turn of events is so sad for two reasons, besides the fact that it must be such a personal inconvenience for you, Lisa.

    First, your article about your trip to Beirut was so informative and interesting. I find it sad that the Israeli government would want to stifle the sort of eye-opening, barrier-breaking reporting in your article. Thanks to your article a lot more people have a much more human view of what goes on in Beirut than they had before. That is certainly the case for this reader.

    Second, so much of your article was about the difficulties imposed by Arab states on Jews and Arabs who want to travel between Israel and the Arab countries. I would think that Israel, which prides itself on its democratic freedoms, would want to demonstrate to the world that it is a freer country than the Arab countries and that it allows its citizens the sort of freedoms that many Arabs can only dream about. Now, I’m afraid, many Arabs will look at the difficulties imposed by Israel on you, Lisa, and they will think that Israeli treatment of Jewish journalists is not much better than Arab treatment of Arab journalists. That is sad and it does not do anybody any good.

    7. Sam
    on December 13th, 2007 at 4:07 pm
  6. Hi Lisa!!!

    I think I can surely say I’m your Nº 1 reader / fan, from Central America, jejeje!!!

    To me, this investigation they are doing to you is SO FOREIGN, I can’t even begin to understand how they can think you did your Lebanon report for publicity, to endanger Israel or worst!!!

    From lovely Costa Rica, I wish you the best of luck in this ordeal and I’m sending you all the positive vibes you’ll ever need to put an end to all of these!!!

    Vivi :-)

    8. Viviam Leal
    on December 13th, 2007 at 5:18 pm
  7. listen to your lawyer and whatever you do, don’t shut up

    9. eamonnmcdonagh
    on December 13th, 2007 at 5:24 pm
  8. There’s obviously some history here between you and one of the bloggers you refer to that we readers don’t know, and it’s clear that neither of you is reacting only on the issues. It may be foolish to stick my head up in the middle, but maybe a reader of both your blogs with views somewhere in the middle and who respects both of you can inject a little proportion.

    “Virulently anti-Arab” is a mis-characterisation IMHO, and I really don’t think he “really, really hates you”.

    Reading between the lines I get a strong impression that each of you has some unfinished business with the other which you are working out indirectly through the blogosphere. Maybe you should just talk it over?

    10. Simon
    on December 13th, 2007 at 7:20 pm
  9. I keep hearing a lot of Israelis even go to visit family in Iran.

    11. Brian Ulrich, aka B.U.
    on December 13th, 2007 at 8:25 pm
  10. There is a vague sense of their trying to pull a Fahima on you – recruit you to their service by threatening you that if you don’t join, they’ll put you away on charges of “contact with a foreign agent”.

    FWIW, this has been standard operating procedure with regard to Palestinians since 1948 (with a huge increase in application of this strategic component used against Palestinians after 1967).

    One of the alarming pieces of this is its use against Jewish Israelis. That’s a new trend, and implies that there has been some sort of redefinition who the “them” are who need to be infiltrated – in other words, the definition by Israel’s security forces of who is “us” and who is “the other” has shifted.

    The “turn spy or we’ll use the force of the state against you” is inexcusable whenever it’s applied, of course. But the change in trend is notable.

    Interestingly, this sort of tactic was also used against Chaplain Yee, the American Muslim chaplain who was in Guantanamo. Apparently, contact with foreign agents is not ok unless you interrogate them – even if you are required to provide confidentiality within your capacity as chaplain. See also (in the U.S.) Sami Al-Arian, who is in jail indefinitely for “contempt of court” due to refusing to testify against purported “terrorists” (he can’t use fifth amendment protections because he’s been “granted” amnesty.)

    I hope you keep things as public as possible – dark deeds are harder to do with daylight being shined on them. Or limelight, in this case.

    12. shunra
    on December 13th, 2007 at 8:54 pm
  11. Stay strong. You da bomb, baby!

    JQ

    13. Jonas
    on December 13th, 2007 at 10:08 pm
  12. (makes gestures of astonishment and outrage, and supportive noises)

    14. Udge
    on December 13th, 2007 at 11:55 pm
  13. It is my understanding that reporters from ‘enemy’ countries do also report from within Israel.
    Now, how can there be a restriction on Israeli reporters reporting from the countries these reporters here are from?
    Isn’t that a bit of a double standard?

    15. tsedek
    on December 14th, 2007 at 12:23 am
  14. At first glance, it is indeed ironic that both sides of the divide are united in their reaction to this present situation. However on second thought, I believe both are equally threatened by you and your work. By dismissing it as “fluff” and denigrating your motives, they hope to get it off the table as soon as possible. For the Israeli extreme right-wingers, what could threaten their political agenda more than mainstream Israelis learning that there is a human face to the “enemy.” It is harder to harbor distrust when we see people like many of us in cafes and clubs, and walking along a promenade amazingly similar to that of Tel Aviv. Of course this does not represent all Lebanese or all Beirutis and you do not make that claim. But it makes us stop for a minute and adjust our perception to take in that they are not all Hizabullah-supporting, assassinating, kidnapping, Jew haters. For extremists on the other side, seeing the face of Israel not as a soldier at a checkpoint, a rightwing settler or a threatening politician, but as a beautiful, soft-spoken, intelligent woman with an attitude of humanism seems to be equally threatening.

    16. Fay
    on December 14th, 2007 at 1:37 am
  15. Aw Lisa. Only I know that you are both a right-wing Zionist lick spittle, and a dangerous, seditious leftist who panders to the Arabs and endangers the security of the state. This is possible only because of your crafty Canadian ways. You don’t fool me. Not for one second.

    Shall I whip up a free Lisa Goldman T-shirt on CafePress and send you the proceeds? I can do that you know…

    17. ck
    on December 14th, 2007 at 3:52 am
  16. “In my response to the investigation, which will be published on Friday in Haaretz newspaper, I raise these questions and more.”

    Printing the answers in your column would be of more value than printing the questions.

    19. Kevin
    on December 16th, 2007 at 12:53 pm
  17. Jumping Jayzus on a crutch! Why do I always miss the important stuff!

    I shall have me a short meditation session and make an effort to guess where this crap comes from…

    Uhu… got it…

    22. snoopythegoon
    on December 20th, 2007 at 4:47 pm

5 Trackbacks

  1. [...] Lisa finally made a statement on her blog, On the Face. She has written for a piece about this situation in Ha’aretz [...]

  2. [...] are two other Israeli journalist who are being charged by the police. Please see Lisa’s blog for more [...]

  3. [...] Blog category. Lisa is getting a lot of attention right now because of the Israeli police’s investigation of her visit to Lebanon last year, but that visit represents her true spirit of openness to others. She has established [...]

  4. [...] Here’s Lisa’s explanation, from her blog, on the current investigation by the Israeli Police. [...]

  5. [...] Israelische Polizei ermittelt gegen Lisa Goldman, die Anfang dieses Jahres mit einem ausländischen Reisepass in den Libanon [...]

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked *

*
*