headermask image

header image

A Muslim Iranian visits Tel Aviv: Big deal or not a big deal?

Here's Hossein on his first morning in Tel Aviv, at my second home local cafe.

He arrived safely yesterday evening, after being detained at Ben Gurion Airport for about an hour while security checked my details (because I'm hosting him). An El Al security officer had already called me early that morning to verify his background before he boarded his flight in Berlin; after I'd answered all the questions (how do you know him, whose idea was it that he visit Israel, how long will he be staying, do you know any other Iranian bloggers who want to visit Israel) the security guy confirmed that Hossein would be allowed to board the flight. So in the end, he was not questioned more than any other “unusual” visitor to super-security-conscious Israel. I guess the letters he was provided by Ben Gurion University and Tel Aviv University, confirming that he was scheduled to give a presentation, helped smooth the way.

While we were walking along Rothschild Boulevard this afternoon, Hossein asked me how average Israelis would respond to him as a Muslim Iranian.

Why don't you just try and see? I answered.

So when we stopped at a money changer's on Allenby Street, where Hossein changed a few dollars and bought a pre-paid SIM card for his mobile phone, I asked the owner – on a hunch – if he spoke Persian.

No, he answered, but my father does.

With me translating, Hossein introduced himself to Seymour, which was the money changer's name, and took his photo. As we were leaving, Seymour said to me, “Tell your friend that I wish him all the best.”

We spent most of our afternoon at the cafe, where Hossein was interviewed for an article that will be published in Haaretz on Tuesday (January 31), using the free WiFi to work on our laptops. I introduced Hossein to everyone and not one person responded with anything but typically laid-back, laconic Tel Aviv warmth along the lines of “Hey man, nice to meet you.”

For me, Hossein's visit is very nice, but not a big deal. For a lot of other people, it seems that it is a very big deal. For some people, it a not-nice very big deal. You can read a bit about the controversy in the responses to Haitham's post.

There was also a flurry of emails between bloggers who contribute to Global Voices Online. A few of them responded negatively to Hossein's announcement about his visit to Israel, with one person accusing him of visiting an “illegal state” with an “occupational government” (sic).

Most of the responses, however, including many from Arab bloggers (Palestinian and non) have been fantastic – warm, thoughtful and encouraging.

Roba, who is Palestinian, gave me her permission to reproduce what she wrote here:

Hossein,

I'm Palestinian, and I say, kudos to you for taking this step.
The only way we, as a modern civilization, will achieve anything is by putting
emotions aside and equipping our intellect in logical discussion, interaction,
and tolerance. Muslims have a long way to catch in these discussions.
I am
looking forward to reading about your trip as well as looking at pictures, try
to visit Haifa, gorgeous coastal city.

Roba Al-Assi

In Israel, Allison and Hanan Cohen (Hebrew link), an Internet columnist and blogger, have written about Hossein's visit. We're going to meet Hanan sometime in the next couple of days.

I'll probably blog regularly about the visit over the coming days, so stay tuned. (pictures, too!)

If you liked my post, feel free to subscribe to my rss feeds

9 Comments so far (Add 1 more)

  1. It's always easier to comment on a movie you've seen. Let's hope Hoder's visit is the first among many by bloggers. I tag Haitham next.

    1. Anonymous
    on March 12th, 2010 at 5:23 pm
  2. I like to look forward to the day when a visit like Hoder's isn't a big deal at all. Until then, though, I guess this kind of thing will startle some people. I hope it startles folks in a good way, a way that makes us all more inclined to question our assumptions and to see one another as created b'tzelem Elohim (in God's image) regardless of where we come from or what we believe.
    What I like about your post is its ordinariness. So, nu? You picked a guy up at the airport, you changed some money, you hung out at a cafe. Like people do. Somehow I think that helps as much as any grand dialogue does — just being people with one another, doing the ordinary things that are part of our lives.

    2. Anonymous
    on March 12th, 2010 at 5:23 pm
  3. Well, it is certainly a big deal for him.
    Hope the visit goes well and there is a lot of learning on both sides.

    3. Anonymous
    on March 12th, 2010 at 5:23 pm
  4. What an incredible life you lead Lisa. How do you meet these fascinating people? I just pass on his website to one of my close friends, another Iranian Moslem, but she doesn't really identify herself with Islam, but rather connects directly to the Koran. The message that Hossein is hoping to get across is exactly what she has been saying to me and her friends. I am glad he is so far, having a positive experience in Israel.

    4. Anonymous
    on March 12th, 2010 at 5:23 pm
  5. Funny, that's what I always tell people I know who are going to visit Israel: Don't miss Haifa, it's beautiful! Also, it has the best falafel :)

    5. Anonymous
    on March 12th, 2010 at 5:23 pm
  6. Haifa has the best shwarma – shwarma sel hazzan.

    6. Anonymous
    on March 12th, 2010 at 5:23 pm
  7. Good luck with the rest of the visit Lisa.
    Have you taken him shopping yet?

    7. Anonymous
    on March 12th, 2010 at 5:23 pm
  8. Lisa,
    My feeling towards this visit was unequivocal: more power to you and the good deeds you do.
    However, after reading a comment by another Iranian (seemingly) on Allison's blog, I got a bit of a shock. I don't know whether you have seen this:
    http://sarbazekuchak.blogspot.com/2006/01/little-goebbels-in-israel-israel-has.html
    This Khorshid guy is quite venomous toward your guest. And seems to have some arguments. It may be good if you could talk with Hosein openly about this.
    Best wishes.

    8. Anonymous
    on March 12th, 2010 at 5:23 pm
  9. Despite everything, Lisa, have you heard of this?

    Hi Ralf. Yes, I read about Hoder’s arrest. I’m not quite sure what to make of it, though, because the story is so far unconfirmed. Lisa

    9. Ralf
    on December 7th, 2008 at 12:25 am

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked *

*
*